You always expect a good production when going to the Royal Exchange as they are an established and well respected theatre company. The world premier of True Love Lies was no exception. Brad Fraser has writen other plays including Cold Meat Party, which came with a warning about its explicit nature. True Love Lies came with no warnings and is said to be quite tame in comparison. However, it is certainly an unflinching look at the complications of human relationships and despite its sometimes sensational content, it certainly wasn’t sensationalist.
It is actually quite a realistic and well observed portrayal of a young, liberal, middle class family in New York. They are open in their attitudes towards life, sex and love but tensions start to arise when Father, Kane and Mother, Carolyn reveal that Kane had a two year gay relationship before he met Carolyn. The reactions between the two children couldn’t be more varied: the daughter, Maddy, finds it quite amusing whereas the younger son, Royce is thrown in to turmoil by the revelations.
The parents are very matter of fact about Kane’s previous relationship and in the interests of maintaining an air of openness, Carolyn invites David for dinner. Things start to go wrong however, when Carolyn accidentally concedes that Kane and David’s relationship was never a ‘proper one’. David politely makes his excuses and leaves, unable to pretend that everything is ok between them. Carolyn’s slip of the tounge reveals her true feelings and shows that despite the outward display of respectability the relationship between Kane and Carolyn is not as secure as she thinks it is.
However David agree’s to employ Kane’s daughter, Maddy, at his restaurant and before long they form an unlikely friendship. They start to have late night meals together in the restaurant and it is not long before Maddy seduces David. The closing scene of the first half involves Maddy, ripping her blouse off and mounting the hapless David. They have sex but that is where the frisson ends, with both parties agreeing that to tell Kane or Carolyn would be pointless and destructive.
Despite their indiscretion they continue to have a friendship and David becomes a father figure to Maddy, noticing that she is begginning to fall for a co- worker at the restaurant. He follows the maturing and development of Maddy with interest and amusement and Brad Fraser may well be hinting at the role which David has never had to play due to his homosexuality.
Meanwhile the youngest son, Royce, is having a mental breakdown. He is being bullied badly at school and is growing resentful that his parents seem more bothered about their own lives then his. This situation comes to a head when Royce goes to Davids restaurant with a shotgun and blames him for his families, failing relations and apparent inability to understand him. He also knows about his sisters fling with him and he see’s this as definitive proof that everyone is debauched and immoral.
Eventually David manages to coax the gun from Royce and make him promise to seek help.
He agrees and the family go some way to repairing themselves, as Carolyn and Kane put their problems aside to support their son and convince him of their love. During these momements it is clear they care deeply about their son and that their family is fully functioning in terms of their closeness and ability to care for one another when it really matters. But despite their love for their children the return of David and has highlighted problems in their relationship which are hard to ignore.
Carolyn begin to question the authenticity of her relationship with Kane and begins to realise what she has always known: Kane still loves David. Carolyn suspects that David and Kane had one last fling whilst she was pregnant with Maddy, she confronts David about this, he denies that it ever happened and it is only later when she tells Kane that Kane panics and admits it. This seals Carolyns belief that their relationship has run its course and the only thing to do is pursue a new life. She moves out, secures a part time job and gains a new freedom and identity that she has never had before.
Meanwhile Maddy is busy plotting an encounter between her father and David as she realises, that what they both shared was special and never went away. Without saying anything to either of them she calls her father to the restaurant, and the two of them are left alone together. The last scene, shows them both sitting down to a meal as though nothing has happened, proving that true love really does lie.
I enjoyed this play because it sent some very important messages about never ignoring your true feelings and the importance in acting on what you believe in. It was fast paced, well writen and well worth the trip out in the cold!